Monday, July 25, 2011

Problem Solving: The Aim Of Critical Thinking

Hello Bloggers! I have discussed the practices of critical literacy and how to engage students in critical literacy in the past two posts. The purpose of today’s post is to explore more deeply the purpose or aim of teachers and students collaborating using critical literacy learning. Critical literacy is a response to injustice and the production of illiteracy in which students and teachers work together to communicate and learn about topics relating to the world to solve injustice. The diversity of teachers and students’ experiences allows them to learn from each other by scaffolding or building upon their knowledge by connecting old and new knowledge.  Unlike high stakes education that I have discussed in previous posts, critical literacy learning has meaning to students because they make personal connections, engage in topics, and perform higher order thinking other than memorization. As a result, students become problem solvers that have the knowledge and skills to fight injustice.
Part of educating students to become critical thinkers or problem solvers involves teaching them to make connections with their experiences to understand and gain new knowledge.  This concept is based on the well known Vygotsky. He believed students learn by scaffolding from their experiences and interacting with their surrounding environment. Also, teachers should start at students’ zone of proximal development. Below is a diagram to help you visualize his theory.

In connection, Freire proposes, “Problem-Posing education affirms men and women as beings in the process of becoming –as unfinished, uncompleted beings in and with a likewise unfinished reality” (65). In other words, people are constantly evolving and learning through their interactions with their environment. They need to be treated not as empty containers, but as people have knowledge that can be built upon. Furthermore, the title Freire creates for his suggested education shows that teachers and students aim should be to problem solve. Moses’ Algebra Project is an example of how Vygotsky and Feire’s pedagogies are being used to by teachers and students collaborating to find a solution to social injustice. Moses explains, “The Algebra Project is not about simply transferring a body of knowledge to children. It is about using that knowledge as a tool to a much larger end (15). The teachers and students set a goal which is like the zone of proximal development.  Also, the teacher is not making students memorize math facts; they are using math literacy as a tool in their environment to fight injustice. Moses states, “It is the floor, not the ceiling, We’re not trying to put constraints or limits on what any group of children might learn” (15). In other words, the teachers have students start from the base and then they are encouraged to build on their knowledge. Jackson and Cooper, who I mentioned in  a previous post, also support Vygotsky and Freire’s works when they claim, Teachers show belief in students “by bridging required content to students’ personal frame of reference” (246).  The bridging of content and students frame of reference is the same as Vygotsky’s concept of students scaffolding from their Zone of Proximal Development.
Collaboration and communication is vital to helping students and teachers problem solve. As I discussed in my last post, teaching talking is a major aspect of critical literacy learning. However, it can be a challenge for teachers to teach conversation. Hilliard states, “We have a major communication problem, especially since few professionals understand language issues either” (102). So, a problem that has to be solved is miscommunication. Similarly, Kohl states,  “It has everything to do with the way in which language is heard and interpreted, with tone, presentation, attitude, implication, and an understanding of how to convey complex meaning in a way that is understood by the spoken-to” (Kohl 151).  I believe miscommunication can be solved by teachers and students practicing conversation. As I mentioned previously, we have to reflect on the way we and our students are talking. Teachers can help students become better talkers and problem solvers by, “Pushing the discussion further with your questions doesn’t ignore or diminish the significance of the students questions if you’re cautious –it simply indicates that you, too, wonder, question, doubt, speculate. In other words, you, too, are a reader who sees the possibility for inquiry in anything you read and seeks others with whom to discuss it” (Probst 54). In other words, teachers have to model the type of question one asks when analyzing and solving problems. Probst digs deeper in the skills required for collaborative problem solving stating conversation “…includes such matters as listening more carefully; calling for, providing, and questioning evidence; accepting and examining other points of view; and dealing tactfully with one another” (59). Delpit, discussed in a previous post, also supports the use of collaborative conversation stating, “I believe students must be taught the codes needed to participate fully in the mainstream of American life, not only by being forced to attend to hollow, inane, decontextualized subskills, but rather within the context of meaningful communicative endeavors; that they must be allowed the resource of the teacher’s expert knowledge, while being helped to acknowledge their own ‘expertness’ as well…” (45). Like Moses and other authors, Delpit suggests that minority students can fight injustice through meaningful conversation. It requires collaboration between teachers and students using their knowledge. Collaboration is also discussed by Jackson and Cooper who state “relationships that are built on genuine dialogue in which students and teachers communicate what’s meaningful and relevant to them both” (246). All in all, teachers and students need to collaborate together through conversation if they are to solve problems in education and other social spheres. It is the teachers job to design an environment that students feel they can talk in.  
I have mentioned inquiry as an element in critical literacy learning before, but I am discussing it again because it sparks problem solving conversation. Wilhelm and Smith argue, “Teachers can meets these situational condition of engagement or flow by constructing inquiry units that both address students’ needs for personal relevance and promote disciplinary understandings that clearly count and have functional value in the world” (233). That is, students engage in a deep flow of learning when inquiry is used in relation to students’ worlds. Moreover, they explain, “Inquiry is not simply thematic study, but the exploration of a question or issue that drives debate in the disciplines and the world” (233). Once again, students and teachers engage inquiry to explore problems found in the real world. Gutierrez describes “A visitor to the school would hear children speaking bilingually in English and Spanish, working collaboratively across subject matter areas” (120). In this case, students are encouraged to connect all of their language and content knowledge to problem solve across disciplines.  In connection, I discovered this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_eyucHMifto  which is on five year olds that create unit themes, problem solve, critically think, and make meaning from authentic activities. When you watch the video you will see these small children fully engaged in learning and solving real world problems, such a dealing with death. Although the students are having great fun doing inquiry activities the teacher points out that they are not nonsense games. The video also points out that questions from peers help these students develop their story telling or talking skills. In many ways the five year olds in this video are learning the same ways that the older students do in Gatto’s butterfly unit, which I discussed last week. Lastly, I want to show my support for this pedagogy by sharing my own experience of collaborative inquiry activities. Like many of my classmates I found trigonometry and geometry difficult to grasp because they are abstract concepts that held no meaning to me. However, when my teacher and my class developed a unit using the math concepts to build bird houses I began to learn and enjoy math. We asked each other questions and worked together problem solving to construct a useful object. Learning had meaning then.
I believe writing functions as a form of communication and help both teachers and students make inquiries and formulate connections. Reif supports this stating,  “Writing is one way of representing and communicating our thinking to others, using experiences, our knowledge, our opinions, and our feelings to inform and negotiate our understandings and misunderstandings of ourselves and the world in which we live” (191). To put it differently, writing is used to “talk” to authors about our feelings, experiences, knowledge and problem solve. This idea relates to Freire’s theory that people and the world are not static. Teachers and students develop or evolve together through conversation. A strategy from my readings that inertest me is the use of Post-it notes to mark thoughts and questions on readings. Gatto and other experts have explained how this form of writing prepares students for meaningful conversation. In fact, I too use Post-It Notes to help me understand academic reading. I would introduce this to a class by modeling my thought process out loud, so students learn the type of questions and comments that are useful to mark on readings using Post-It Notes.
 It is clear that modeling is a part of my pedagogy. Therefore, I think teachers should model how to collaborate, communicate, and problem solve. Egawa states, “When coaching is part of a coordinated and interdisciplinary literacy program, all of these educators can work together to create the real changes needed to support all struggling students” (296). Teachers practice what they preach when they practice the same skills they ask their students to perform. The work from Egawa demonstrates how literacy coaches and teachers can work together to solve the problem struggling students getting the education they deserve to succeed. Specifically, Egawa explains “Teaching includes about one’s practice, and coaches can support that thinking by bringing learning and literacy expertise to enhance your subject matter knowledge” (298). Just like we ask students to connect their knowledge of multiple literacies and disciplines, we also must practice sharing and connecting our content knowledge with our coworkers to make a change in the present failing education system. I will be student teaching next spring and I know I would love to have the support from teachers and my peers to problem solve issues that come up when I students teach. The following video, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4ZnMLflGq4  demonstrates how student teachers communicate and inquire with the use of technology. If teachers are educated in college the importance of talk and problem solving then they will be better prepared to teach their students how to perform these skills.
In this post I have described the importance of collaboration and problem solving among teachers and students through conversation, writing, and authentic activities. Thus, it only makes sense that we evaluate our students based on these skills. Gatto states, “I fill out report cards with each child and we decide together what the grades and comments should be. This way, report cards are meaningful documents to the children, and when parents receive them, their children can explain and discuss the grades and comments” (86). Again, communication and meaningful learning is integrated in how students are graded on their performance. Allington also argues, “If we are interested in a broader view of  “intellectual life’ (Vygotsky 1978) that is exhibited on standardized achievement tests, then we will also have to consider the use of other tools to better assess a variety of potential outcomes” (284). He also supports the idea that high stakes test based on memorization skills are not valid and that teachers must think of ways to evaluate students on higher level thinking skills such as problem solving and critical thinking. It is also evident that Vygotsky’s theory plays a major role in changing/improving education and is the base of many author’s theories that I have talked about in my blog.
I hope by reading this point you gain new insight in the importance of collaboration between teachers and students and that higher learning involves communication, inquiry, and problem solving. Through critical literacy learning teachers and students gain meaning from experiencing the world together and education is no longer about filling students up with facts. Ultimately, the new aim for education is creating problem solvers that can change the world and stop the injustice created by neoliberal policies, high stakes test, miscommunication, and sameness as fairness. As always, please come back soon for a new post on literacy!

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Engaing Students in Critical Litercay Learning

Good morning Bloggers! Last we I discussed critical literacy learning as the literacy topic of the week. Critical literacy learning involves the collaborative efforts of teachers and students learning together through conversation and multiple literacies. I would like to continue to discuss critical literacy learning more deeply this week with a focus on how to engage students in critical literacy learning. Lynn Gatto’s work is mainly used in the post because she masterfully cultivates critical literacy in her class. She engages students by ignoring commercial literacy programs and creating her own units that are rich collaborative work, meaningful activities, and multiple litearcies You will find that many of the themes I have discussed in previous weeks are integrated in critical literacy practices. 
Gatto does not use the commercial literacy programs and commercial products created for a scientific approach that satisfies high stakes education. She states, “Textbook publishers’ expensive sales brochures claim their programs will help students become successful, motivated, confident readers and writers”, but she does not believe them (74). Moreover, she goes on to explain that NCLB has impacted every classroom and that “Most districts are adopting curriculum and textbook programs designed to prepare students for these tests” (74). You may remember the post on neoliberalism in which I discuss how Apple and Lipman argue the negative effects neoliberalism and high stakes testing has on both teachers and students. The agenda is to make a profit and mainstream students. When Gatto’s district began conforming to the Reading First Grant she refused to buy into it.  Freire’s work on the pedagogy of the oppressed supports Gatto’s decision to go against the commercial literacy program. As an example, Freire claims, “The capability of banking education to minimize the students’ creative power and to stimulate their credulity serves the interests of the oppressors, who care neither to have the world revealed nor to see it transformed” (54). In all, the authors I have mentioned claim that policies and commercial or Banking Education do not stimulate students critical thinking because their agenda is based on mainstreaming and profit to suite them.
Instead she designs her own literacy units that stem from silent sustained reading.  Gatto explains, “My approach is to provide experiences and problems that engage students in expanding their existing literacy practices in order to construct and use new ones” (75). Overall, her she engages students by introducing experiences and problems that students can scaffold off of their present knowledge. To accomplish this she considers “the individual students, planning carefully, selecting appropriate materials and activities, and adjusting activities” (77). It is clear from this that she is not the giver of knowledge and does not support what Freire describes as Banking Education, which is when teachers treat students as objects to fill knowledge with (52). Her role is “…constructing an atmosphere where the children see themselves as valuable to the process of learning within the classroom” (75).
She creates a community for learners to have engaging discussions and activities. As I mentioned last week, students need to be treated as members of the academic community. Gatto explains, “Within a community of learner’s framework I make sure the children in my class have multiple opportunities for literacy events and practices within social contexts” (75). In other words, her students are constantly practicing literacy with their peers. This refers back to Allington and Rief from last week who stress students need to be immersed in continuous literacy practice. It is taken a step further by Gatto who designs her classroom off of her unit themes. As supported when she states “I begin every unit by crating an environment for immersion into the topic” (78). Furthermore, she illustrates this idea when she describes how she filled the classroom with books, periodicals, posters, and models relating to the unit theme on butterflies.  

Another practice she uses to engage students in critical literacy is using multiple literacies that are authentic to students. Gattos students can build connections and gain real meaning from the literacies that they practice in class.  For example, in their butterfly unit they read James and the Giant Peach. They were able to connect science with English in a cross discipline study on insects.  Another example is the two times in the butterfly unit in which students connect the litearcaies of America and Mexico. The students were not simply translating their writing from Englsih to Spanish, but expanding their community and literacy practices. A bilingual class was called upon to enter in their community to help them with their task of translating and revising a letter. Also, they cared about performing the activity because there was a meaningful goal.  As the unit progressed they began to care about the butterflies, so they wanted to write a letter to the Mexican government in regards to preserving them. Gatto was luck to have a school with bilingual classes. After exploring bilingualism in a previous post and reading this aspect of Gatto’s teaching I wanted to find a way that I could incorporate bilingual activities for my students. After some research and thought I found penpals via Skype© a great way to include not only bilingual cultures and literacies, but technology literacy as well. Here is a video clip of fifth graders communicating with German students via Skpe, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rG4Vt8lQ8dU.
Most importantly Gatto engaged her students because her unit was authentic. Gatto’s persistence for her students to have an authentic education reminds me so much of another famous teacher, Ms. Frizzle from the popular Magic School Bus series. I have provided a link to show my connection between the two teachers, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nPp0tCLIEFM . After watching the clips you will notice that both teachers first engage students by immersing them in the unit topic through the classroom environment. Then they have students physically and mentally interact with the topic through questioning, problem solving and field trips. Another supporter of authentic education is Freire who explains, “The teacher’s thinking is authenticated only by the authenticity of the students’ thinking. The teacher cannot think for her students, nor can she impose her thought on them. Authentic thinking, thinking that is concerned about reality, does not take place in ivory tower isolation, but only in communication” (58). One again, it is stressed that learning must be student centered with students doing the thinking. It involves students interacting with reality or the real world through conversation.  All of the activities created by Gatto were based off of questions students had at the start of the unit. As Gatto states, “Authentic questioning generates in-depth and sustained student conversation or dialogical instruction” (75). Real thought provoking questions lead her students to have deep conversations. Similarly, last week I talked about the importance of inquiry in the classroom studied by Wilhelm and Smith.  Dialogical instruction or inquiry happens when students participate in deep meaningful conversation that leads them on the pursuit for knowledge and answers.
These conversations lead to enriching activities that had meaning to students. It is said by Gatto “Authentic literacy includes activities that allow children to communicate about real things of interest to them and to a real audience”(76).  So, authentic activities involve students performing real world tasks for an audience. I think an audience engages students because they have a reason to do the activity. This supported by Rief who claims an audience is needed when writing. Examples of authentic activities in Gatto’s butterfly unit include trips to museums, writing to local newspaper, and designing and running a butterfly museum vivarium for the public. I was amazed at the responsibility the students took in researching, communicating with public (governments, newspapers, peers, teachers, community members), and organizing a museum. In all, the butterfly unit supports Gatto’s comment, “My classroom was a community of learners in which students and teacher work together in goal-directed activity” (85).  Freire supports the idea of teacher and student working together to learn when he states, “Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction, by reconciling the poles of the contradiction so that both are simultaneously teachers and students” (53). To put it differently, education can be improved when both teacher and students agree to learn together.
The following line from Gatto helped me consider how I would use her pedagogy to promote critical literacy in my future classroom, “I use their experiences, interests, history, culture, language, and literacy practices to develop the literacy program in my classroom. The children know they are valued as learners within our classroom. Their ideas and opinions count…In my classroom, literacy is the bridge between the exciting and meaningful hands-on unit of study and the minds-on construction of knowledge that is central to providing challenging curriculum” (88). Like Gatto, I will take my students’ interests, backgrounds, literacies, and experiences into consideration when developing authentic units. I have mentioned several times that teachers must have a positive relationship with students to create lessons that will benefit them and match their learning styles. Furthermore, I will show that I value them as contributing members of the academic community by taking their ideas and opinions into account. Inquiry or dialogical learning will be vital if I am to achieve this. Students must be heard and I wish to learn from them during inquiry conversations. I found that the students involved in the butterfly unit took on a lot of responsibility and challenged themselves. They were in charge of their learning and as a result they gained meaning and performed higher functioning thinking because of it. As a result of the success of Gatto’s butterfly unit, I would like to mimic these qualities in my own units. Already, I have begun to brainstorm ideas for authentic units and I came up with an idea for a newspaper unit. Inquiry would be necessary for students to brainstorm ideas for running the newspaper and writing articles. Authentic activities would also be key like in the butterfly unit because students would have to take filed trips and communicate with community members to perform research for articles. Of course, multiple literacies would be incorporated as well because students would have to read and talk about the production of newspapers and topics they wish to write about. I found this article, http://barnegat.patch.com/articles/barnegat-high-schools-newspaper-a-class-act, about a class that runs their own newspaper that I can use for the future.
I hope you have gained something from this post my blogger folowers! Check back for more discussion on literacy.

Monday, July 18, 2011

Critical Literacy Learning

Hello Bloggers! This week I will continue to discuss diversity in literacy with a focus on critical literacy learning or learning through literacy. Students use multiple literacies in school to learn. Specifically, math reading, and writing are ways that students think and learn. There are a variety of ways literacies can be taught and multiple views on how students critically learn using literacies. Continuous practice of literacy, multiple texts, critical class discussion, engagement, and connection are some common topics related to critical literacy learning. Professionals present many possibilities for students using literacy to learn and there are drawbacks to their theories.
 It is suggested by many professionals in the field that students need to be immersed in the literacy they are being taught. Learning to speak French comes to mind in this case because I was able to appreciate and deeply learn the language when I was in a community that used it regularly. Supporting this is Allington who states, “struggling readers need high quality instruction all day long, in every class, as well as a well-crafted daily intervention class” (275). In other words, students need constant practice and reinforcement in critical literacy skills. Rief also concludes students need time to practice literacy when she suggests, “We need to give students ample opportunities to write on a continuous basis, with choices of topics and genres that engage their interest and/or to which they can connect” (192). Like Allington, Rief stresses the importance of routine practice of literacy skills. The drawback is that some groups of students are not provided the time experiences they need to learn literacy and there is not enough time in the school day to provide students adequate time using literacy.  For instance, Moses argues, “…the most urgent social issue affecting poor people and people of color is economic access. In today’s world, economic access and full citizenship depend crucially on math and science literacy” (5).  That is, groups of students are denied access to math and science literacies, which in turn is denying students economic success. From the information presented by the three authors it is clear that the first crucial step for students to enage in critical litearcy learning is for them to have routine access to it.

Another common suggestion is that students need a diversity of texts. Allington explains in his study “… far more students were routinely engaged in academic work in these classrooms that was the case in more typical classroom, largely because having a variety of texts available meant that virtually all students could find texts that they were able to read accurately, fluently, and with comprehension” (278) Teachers provided managed choice to students by allowing them to choose literature from a selection of books they picked. As a result, students are able to use critical thinking skills because they are choosing texts that math their learning level.  I have observed several teachers that provide students choices in the novels and projects they do. There students appreciated having claim over their work and were willing to work hard because they picked topics they were intersted in. Likewise, Wilhelm and Smith explain to “maximize textual power and diversify literate skills, we need to put different kinds of texts with different readerly demands and rewards together in conversation with each other” (238). To expand knowledge and literate skills a variety of texts needs to provided in the classroom. Furthermore, Wilhelm and Smith believe, “Alternative texts already count in the world and in students’ lives” (238). Alternative texts or popular texts are important in students’ lives. When they are matched to traditional texts students are able to make connections, which is a part of critical literacy learning. Companies such as Sparknotes have already began to market on this with their comic books based on classics such a Romeo and Juliet. Here is a link to multiple Romeo and Juliet comic books for my curious followers http://www.barnesandnoble.com/s/romeo-and-juliet?store=ALLPRODUCTS&dref=1,52&startat=1&size=.   If you read the discriptions of a few of them you will find the general theme remains the same while alterations, such as the setting be in the future, have been made. I think the ideas is to get students to think critically about concepts/themes before jumping in to a high level litearcy like Shakespeare. In a previous blog I discuss how Gee argues the imporatnce of a variety of popular texts that match girls and boys interests. One could argue the negative to diversity of texts in school is that students are not prepared for the standardized curriculum created by the government. Also, supporters of ‘sameness as fairness would say a diversity of literacy results in an unfair education.  On the other hand, I mentioned in a previous post that sameness as fairness is not actually fair as discussed by Gutierrez. Further counter arguing the stance that diversity of texts is not a good method are Wilhelm and Smith stating, “Given the headlong push for coverage, exacerbated by information-driven standardized tests, students are often unable to develop competence and control, or display it any visible way, before being asked to once again confront their ignorance head-on as the next disconnected topic is introduced” (239). Once again, I stress with the support of the authors that students need a variety of text, so they are confident and can incease their litearcy skills.
Discussion or communicating is another technique to help students in critical literacy learning. Inquiry is the base of Wilhelm and Smith’s study and they suggest “Inquiry is not simply thematic study, but the exploration of a question or issue that drives debate in the disciplines and the world” (233). The critical thinking of inquiry involves academic debate or conversation among students.  Critical thinking happens when students use their literacy skills to explore a an issue that involves deep thinking. Along the same lines Allington  “…found discussion-based classrooms more effective at enhancing reading and writing achievement after controlling for prior achievement and other background variables” (278). Literacy skills are improved when students learn from each other through discussion.  Allington mentions the drawback to discussion is when students’ levels and other variables are not considered by the teacher prior to the discussion based lesson. Class discussion fails when not carefully planned and facilitated by teachers. As an example of the planning that is involved in discussion based lessons, here is a link to a lesson I created for a unit on The Great Gatsby, http://www.scribd.com/fullscreen/60286767?access_key=key-yc1jh5yf0m7j7vnlenn. As you can see it is student centered, but organized so students stay focus on the goal of critically thinking and inquiring about texts. Writing also translates as a form of discussing or communicating with others. Rief explains, “We want our efforts to mean something; we want to know that our words made someone think, or feel, or learn” (192). To put it differently, students need to practice writing to a clear audience, so they have a purpose for writing. Writing means something to students when they write as if they are discussing their topic with peers. Moreover, Moses highlights the value of students discussing and using their voice in his Algebra Project claiming, “Young people finding their voice instead of being spoken for is crucial part of the process” (19). All in all, critical literacy learning involves peer learning and not just the teacher relaying information.
Engagement through connections is also vital in critical literacy learning. Allington explains in her study, “As these teachers encouraged literate discussion, they also made overt connections between knowledge, skills, and ideas and across lessons, days, units, classes, and grades” (284). So, there is continuity between what students are learning that guides them to make connections. In connection with Allington, Wilhelm and Smith argue, “Developing the strategies and stances of a reader or writer depended on upon first seeing the connections between one’s current identities, values, and strengths (as a garner who likes to make decisions and is good at evaluating choices, for example) and the new identity to be developed (as a reader who can see implied patterns and therefore discern subtexts that will help one understand irony, for example” (241). Improving literacy skills requires students to make connections between their old knowledge with new knowledge. This is also called scaffolding. Moses also discusses engaging students through connections by stating math needs to be taught as a unified subject (as oppose to geometry, algebra, etc) and students need to be taught math literacy in relation to how it is used in the real world. Students will find meaning from the literacies they learn if they are able to make the connections to the real world and themselves.
Most importantly students need to be treated as a part of the community and disciplines they are learning. Joining the Honors English Society at my college made me feel a part of the community of Englsih majors and I grew to take my Englisg studies even more seriousley. Therefore, I think students will be more likely In Allington’s study the teachers, “fostered students’ identities as learners and their sense of agency as participants” (285). The students are treated as important active participants in the academic community. They begin to identify themselves as learners. Wilhelm and Smith state, “In any discipline, the learner is expected to continually proceed toward doing and thinking about the discipline more like experts do” (240). In order for students to learn a discipline or literacy they have to be guided to think and perform the skills as experts do. Moses also argues the importance of students becoming equal citizens and participants in math literacy in his study.
In sum, there are many views on critical literacy learning, but there are some common themes among them. There are positives and negatives to the suggestions and theories on critical literacy learning. I think the importance of looking at various professionals’ theories is to take from them the strategies and methods that work for you and your students.  Please check back next week for a new post on literacy.  

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Idenity and Literacy

Hello bloggers! These past weeks I have discussed topics involving diversity and literacy. This week I want to take a close look at the relationship between identity and the new or digital age of literacy. Students use their personal and school literacies to find their identities. In turn, school and larger society influence students’ identities. Specifically, we can see how schools influence gender identity and type of profession students will be fit for. It is important to remember that students are searching for that their identities and to critically look at how the literacy we provide influences them during this search.
Adolescence is a time when students are figuring out who they are. In past weeks I have discussed multiple literacies and multiple cultures. These are just two aspects of our students’ identities that students bring into class. Identity is complex and diverse, so students struggle to find themselves. Williams states, “it is a time when boys and girls alike are torn between forming an individual sense of identity and establishing group identities; gender is a central part of these explorations and negotiations” (2004, pg. 512).  In other words, students in their teen years formulate multiple identities. This relates to how students code switch or choose what literacy they are to use depending on the situation they are in. Part of teenagers’ search is observing the people and media around them. Supporting this claim is Williams that explains, “But the reality is that most adolescents spend a great deal of time and energy observing adults, popular culture, and their peers and then obsessing about how to interpret  and incorporate what they see into their values and actions” (2007, pg. 301). Teenagers are critical observers of their world around them and use the information from adults, peers, popular culture (through media and technology) to create their identities.
Since we are adults that students see every school day that provide them with multiple literacies we have an impact of their identities. Moreover, we bring to the class room our own expectations or assumptions of who our students should be. As Williams states, “The troubling aspect of any discussion of cultural constructions of identity is that we must inevitably engage in generalizations that, if we are not careful, can become calcified ways of perceiving individuals and result in rigid equations about behavior” (2007, pg.  302). Generalizations about our students can lead to false views of who our students are.  For instance, assumptions are made based on the literacy that students use. As a result, their school career can drive them to certain profession.  Gee asserts, “teenagers from different social classes fashion themselves in language as different kinds of people oriented in quite different ways toward the ‘new time’ stemming from the new capitalism” (2000, pg.412). To put it differently, Gee believes that students are drawn to one of two paths of the “new capitalism” depending on their social class. Furthermore, he describes the languages as, “social languages are distinctive in that they are sued to enact, recognize, and negotiate different socially situated identities and to carry out different socially situated activities” (2000, 413). Social languages students use are a part of their identities and the activities or type of work they will perform. The two identities maintain the social hierarchy as described by Gee,“ Though both versions often involve teamwork, one version focuses on technical social languages and deep conceptual  understanding for future symbol analysts, while the other focuses on collaborative talk and skills, often in everyday language, for future enchanted workers” (2000, 415). Based on Gee’s work the pedagogies schools use sort students into categories with one group at the top of the New Capitalism or technology driven capitalism.
Gender identity is also influenced by pedagogies and generalizations used in schools. It is generalization that boys are influenced violence in fiction writing; therefore, curriculum lacks the genres and themes that many boys enjoy in literacy. Williams points out, “These kind of literacy practices to which boys are often drawn-connected to action, violence, and popular culture- are usually prohibited in the classroom where the emphasis is often on ‘high-culture’ literature driven by character and nuance” (2004, pg. 512). Despite that many high schools curriculum includes the violent and action packed Odyssey or Gilgamesh, boys are told to refrain from creating their own adventure stories. It is explained by Williams that, “Schools  have traditionally assumed a civilizing mission as well as an academic one, and socializing boys away from violence, unruly behavior, and the popular culture that celebrated such actions is part of that mission” (2004, pg.  512). Basically, schools feel that they have to tame boys aggressive ways. Unfortunately, boy’s creativity is squashed and they lose opportunities to role play. Action or adventure stories provide boys opportunities to role play being heroes and taking on bigger responsibilities (2004, Williams). Girls are also influenced by school practices. Most agree that girls are better at literacy skills than boys. Consequently, “By quietly doing their work well, girls also may find that do not receive as much of the teacher’s time and consideration” (Williams, 302). They do not get the feedback from their teachers to push their skills to a higher level. In addition, Williams argues that girls are more submissive than boys, so they follow the rules and do not take chances. Boys and girls are also not provided equal experience with technology and digital literacy. As we have learned from Gee, technology plays a major role in New Capitalism, so students must be provided a pedagogy that incorporates digital literacy. Williams supports, “The astonishing growth of the computer and video game industry as a dominant force in popular culture has reinforced the sense that boys are dominating computer use in terms of interest and abilities”(2007, pg. 303). All in all, students need to use their creativity with digital litaercy.
Evidence from the authors proves that we need to evaluate how the pedagogies we use influence our students’ identities. Instead of forcing students to fit generalizations, we must provide them equal experience with the digital literacy that is needed in today’s world and opportunities to use literacy to explore their identities. For instance, “Adolescents role play board and video games –it offers a way to transcend the often powerless world of children into a fictional world where they can ‘claim power and privileges they could never claim in real life” (2004, pg. 513). They use popular culture and technology to find their identities through creativity and games. Another way to help students in their search for identity is to allow them to tell their stories while teaching them how to use digital literacies that will be vital when entering the work force. I am reminded of a friend that kept a digital journal all four years of high school where she was able to socialize with others. In a school setting the site, Center for Digital Story telling http://www.storycenter.org/stories/index.php?cat=5   is an excellent tool to get students using literacy to express themselves. I recommend you watch a few students’ digital stories because you will be amazed at the well organized and profound stories they share using technology. Topics such as abuse, alcoholism, and poverty are found in the stories. Burke too argues that students need technology skills when he states, “ In addition to such technology-based approaches, I have explored the use of various protocols originally designed to facilitate discussion in meetings and the world of business but which adapt themselves well to the classroom and develop skills kids need to succeed in the world of work” (2007, pg. 161).  Like the other authors, Burke suggests that students use digital literacy. Specifically, he explains how he uses School Loop to facilitate online discussions. In sum, students should not be subjected to generalizations, but offered to explore their identities through a variety of literacies that include their interests with popular culture and technology.