Monday, June 27, 2011

What is fair education?

Hello Bloggers! This week I will focus on the concept of “sameness as fairness” in literacy education.  The concept causes much debate in the education world. Topics such as neoliberalism , NCLB, and diversity from previous weeks will be brought up again in connection with this week’s topic.  “Sameness as fairness” is the idea that a fair education for all students means giving all students the same education.  Over the course of the week I have struggled to decide my stance on this issue. After carefully looking several professional’s views I have decided that I am against “sameness as fairness”. The main reason why I am against “sameness as fairness” is because it takes away from diversity.
It is mentioned that neoconservatives and NCLB support the concept of “sameness as fairness”. Gutierrez explains, “The domain of literacy, the subject matter focus of the neo-conservative and neo-liberal educational agenda, serves as the most significant example of the unequal effects produced by policies that only favor dominant groups with economic, social, and political capital (111). As I mentioned in my previous blog, standardized tests and mainstreaming limits diversity and supports only one group of people. Later on Gutierrez claims “There is a perfect storm at work as the national educational agenda and anti immigrant hysteria combine with neo-conservative narratives of fear around  national security, heightened xenophobia, and neo-liberal goals of marketplace reform, privatization, and the larger ideologies of common culture, common language, and common values” (114). In essence, the political atmosphere is driving the idae that sameness or commonality is positive. Moreover, ‘sameness as fairness” corresponds with the idea of   “colorblind” practices. People do not acknowledge diversity and treat everyone the same. The problem with this is that there is diversity and it can not be ignored in the class room.
The main reason for “sameness as fairness” not being an effective approach is because every student is different, so various methods need to be used when teaching diverse classes. The following article, “Sameness does not Mean Fairness” http://academic.udayton.edu/race/04needs/affirm11.htm , explores how the concept is not effective because it “normalizes only one approach to performance” (Sturm and Guinier). Also, the study examines that using the same education practices is not fair because white males do better than females and non white males. Also, “cultural experience is what makes something relevant and meaningful”, so culture and variety need to be included in the classroom (Jackson and Cooper 251). This can not be achieved if teachers are “color blind” and teaching one narrow way of learning. Gutierrez describes that “writing has become a disembodied practice in the classroom for both students and teachers; that is, detached from literacy practices and contexts that bring meaning and purpose to people in sense-making activity” (111). Writing has no meaning to students because they can not connect to it.  Purcell-Gates tells the story of a student named Donny who had difficulty learning literacy the same way his peers were taught. Donny had difficulty because  he did not have the literacy knowledge or “concepts children acquire during their preschool years, during the years preceding the beginning of the formal literacy instruction, in kindergarten and first grade, in reading, writing and printed language” , while his peers did (124). His teachers taught him as if he had the literacy experiences his peers did instead of changing their teaching practice and providing him with the experiences he needed. It is evident from the various professionals work that “sameness as fairness” is not fair.
I believe that there are better teaching practices that provide all students with quality education instead of the same education. As Gurtierrez states, “The ‘sameness as fairness’ framework must be replaced with race-, class-, and gender- conscious equity framework that will make such inequities visible and a humanist vision of education reality” (121). In other words, we have to acknowledge diversity and use a different approach to teaching. Carter, discussed in Ladson-Billings work, was determined that all of his students were to learn to read and write. In that way he treated them all the same, but he also made lessons relatable and meaningful to his students. “Each group made suggestions for change and the students began a rough draft of the story. Carter had the students compare their rough drafts with the premises on which their stories were based” (Ladson-Billings 114). His students related to what they were writing about and all of their voices were heard when they performed collaborative work revising their stories. Jackson and Cooper also support students voices being hear when they state, “educators comb through research to make judgments about how to improve adolescent learning, but they rarely use the most valid, informative source to determine student needs: the student themselves” (246). Clearly, it is vital to listen to our students if we are to create lessons that will engage and connect to them.  I once had to help students practice for the listening part of ELA Regents Exam. They disliked the practice exam and were detached from the listening passage. So, I started asking them questions about listening: In what circumstances do you listen the most? When is listening important to you? Do you like to listen to music or books on tape? The questions jumped started a discussion about listening and the students were able to see the importance of practicing listening skills. Moreover, I found that they liked listening to music, so I facilitated a lesson where they practiced listening using their favorite types of music. My method is supported by Jackson and Cooper when they state, “Frames of reference based on concepts from disciplines provide entry points for bridging student culture to curricular content” (251). That is, find out students’ base knowledge or experience with the concepts that are being taught to guide them to the content material. Students need to be hooked into the lesson and the teacher has to help them scaffold their knowledge.
 Fairness is providing every student with adequate and effective education. Adequate and effective education does not mean providing the same education to students. In order for education to be effective teachers must use practices that will match individual students learning styles and cultures. We have to make an effort to learn about our students, so that we can provide meaningful lessons that students can connect and expand their knowledge with.  


Monday, June 20, 2011

Assessment and Literacy

Dr. Tuck states that, “ after all of these years of common schooling,  we still have no real way of knowing if students are learning”, and I have to agree with her. This week I will continue to discuss literacy, but with the connection literacy has to assessment. Delpit, Hilliard, and Luna take a close look at the relationship between language and how students are assessed. Carini writes about assessing students by ‘describing’. After reading their works I have come to the realization that the assessments that we use today do not tell us if our students are learning because they are biased, not valid, and do not reveal the actual process students take when learning. We need to let go of the high stakes or mainstream testing and hold on to evaluating students based on their progress and learning process. In order to do this, we have to involve students in their own assessments.
As of right now there is no real way of finding out what students have learned because assessments are created and targeted for one group of students, which is the white middle class. Specifically, high stakes tests are made for mainstream students with out diversity in mind. Assessments are closely related to literacy as Hilliard states, “…testing and assessment, as we now see them in education, are rooted in and dependent upon language” (97). Part of the reason why assessments are not effective or accurate is because only one form of literacy is used. As supported by Hilliard who claims, “the results of standardized testing favor children who speak common American English simply because these children are able to respond to questions that are couched in a familiar language  based upon  familiar experiences” (98). It is clear that children who grew up using common American English have an advantage over students that use other literacies.  Delpit provides an example of an African American women who “none of the companies that hired her could move past her language to appreciate her expertise” (38).  Similar to how the companies evaluated the woman as a potential employee based on her literacy and not her actual knowledge; some teachers evaluate students based on the literacy they use to share their knowledge instead of the actual knowledge they have learned.
Luna also comments on how people assume assessments should be standardized stating “this assumption –that mismatches between students’ diverse abilities and standardized practices indicate a difficulty within the student, rather than within the academic context –supports the provision of academic accommodations” (600).  In other words, it is seen that the standardization of assessments is not the problem, but students who do not fit in the main stream are the problem.  These students are forced to fit the main stream by being labeled and provided with accommodations instead of assessments changing. Even with accommodations, diverse learners are limited in expressing what they have learned. Carini’s idea of “manyness” goes along with Luna’s work.  She claims that there are so many students to educate and assess that we leave some behind (168).  Later on Carini explains that diverse students are seen as “…not us or ours. They threaten ‘our’ standards as teachers, as parents, as a school, as a nation. By lumping them together, we are sorting them out: They don’t fit into our picture of school, teaching, and learning. ‘Our’ solidarity as a community is affirmed at the expense of their individuality”(168). In essence, all students are forced to fit the main stream because they do not want students to challenge the norm. Also, it is easier to assess students as if they all learned the same standard way as oppose to creating assessments for all diverse learners. After years of common schooling the same assessments are being used because there is a false validity to them. It is believed that they are valid because upper white children achieve high sores. Moreover, there is no way to separate their knowledge with the skills they learned from growing up in their particular culture (Hilliard).
I firmly believe that we need to involve students in the assessment process. Involving students in the creation of assessments would allow for us to accurately assess students’ learning. In addition, we could observe and assess students learning process along with the final product.  Another reason for involving students in their own assessment is because it reduces the stress and fear that high stakes tests typically causes them. Students’ feelings need to be taken in to account because their emotions affect their performance.  Describing is a form of assessment that Carini discusses.  It involves closely looking at the journey students take to learning material. Unlike standard assessments, describing is not about hastily judging, but honoring the process of learning (Carini).  I like this concept because it shows respect for students. The teacher looks at the process and final product before deciding a final evaluation. From asking two female students that are labeled with learning disabilities, Luna learned that providing students with choices and not having restricting time limits are ways to improve assessments for diverse learners. This shows that students input is valuable in forming assessments that will really show what students have learned.
Inviting students to have a say in how they are assessed does not mean that expectations we have for them should decline. As Delpit explains, “the object is not to lower standards or just teach what is interesting to the students, but to find the students’ interests and build an academic program around them” (Delpit 45).  In fact, working with students on assessment and curriculum would challenge them more. If they have a say in their education they will be more likely to care about learning and work hard at it.  The  video,  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VXCE3BnMTsc&feature=grec_index,  demonstrates how involving students in the assessment process engages students in the learning process and helps them realize what they have learned along with what they need to work on.  In particular, I liked the segment of the video that suggests allowing students to take part in creating rubrics and evaluating themselves. Besides involving students in the assessment process, we can take also examine what other professionals are doing. For instance, Luna suggests learning about how elementary teachers are using alternative ways to assess students. 
All in all, finding a real way of knowing what students have learned involves students having a say in how they area assessed. We need to let go of the idea that standardized tests are valid and embrace diversity. It will take getting to know students as individuals and appreciating their unique learning processes. Please check back next week for a new discussion on literacy.

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Neliberalism's Effect on Literacy Education.

Hello bloggers! I hope as you continue to follow my blog you gain an understanding of the importance of diverse literacy education. This week I will continue to discuss literacy education; specifically, I want to discuss the effect neoliberalism has on the education of literacy. In the simplest terms, neoliberalism is the support of policies that promote privatization in public spheres that are regulated by the government. When there is a problem in one if the spheres, such as education, neoliberals have a private outsource solve it. Apple’s definition of neoliberals is “they are guided by a vision of the weak state. Thus, what is private is necessarily good and what is public is necessarily bad. Public institutions such as schools are ‘blackholes’ into which money is poured –and then seemingly disappears…” (38). In other words, public schools are seen as money pits, so private schools and other ways to make them more profitable come into play. Vouchers are just one example of how neoliberal policies leaves the problem of education or challenge of reforming education to private sources. Neoliberalism negatively effects literacy education in several ways.

Students are seen as products and consumers instead of individual people. They are seen as consumers by private companies that offer money to schools. One example that I find shocking is Channel One, a for-profit network that gave financially low schools equipment in return for having students watch the channel every day.  Some could argue that this is a great opportunity for students to be exposed to digital literacy. As an English teacher, I can see how incorporating watching the news could benefit students in a unit on journalism or public speaking; however, I can not see it be useful everyday.  Moreover, “the technology is hardwired  so that only Channel One can be received, but also mandatory advertisements for major fast foods, athletic wear…Thus, under a number of variants of neliberalism not only are schools transformed into market commodities, but so too now are our children” (Apple 42). Clearly, the students are being targeted as consumers as education is placed second. This reminds me so much of M. T. Anderson’s young adult novel Feed.  If you have not read I recommend that you do; please read the following review http://blogcritics.org/books/article/book-review-feed-by-mt-anderson/.  The novel takes place in the future where children and adults are directly connected to the internet or “feed” implant in their brain. They are constantly bombarded by advertisements and children are educated by the “feed”.  An example of privatization in the novel is the following line, “Of course everyone is like, da da da, evil corporations, oh they’re so bad, we all say that, and we all know they control everything. I mean, it’s not great, because who knows what evil shit they’re up to. Everyone feels bad about that. But they’re the only way to get all this stuff, and it’s no good getting all pissy about it, because they’re still going to control everything whether you like it or not” (Anderson 49).  The character describes how corporations have taken over because they need “stuff’. Students are also seen as products. Apple states that there is a second part of neoliberalism, “willing to spend more state and/or private money on schools, if only the schools meet the needs expressed by capital”. In essence, students need to meet the standards because a lot of money is going into “making them”.

National and state standards along with high stakes tests are used to make public education worth the money put in to it.  After taking several regents, the SATs, and this weekend the CST for teacher certification I still ask myself the same question, “How is this extremely long multiple choice test really going to tell someone I have a sufficient amount of knowledge on this topic? Unfortunately, teachers “teach to the test” because they want their students to succeed, yet students miss out on learning what is outside the tests. Specifically, academic or scientific literacy is taught to students so that they pass high stakes exams; however, we are in a new age where that form of literacy will not help students in the real world. As Alvermann states, “I would also have us take note of a challenge that will grow in magnitude as NCLB- driven policies make their weight felt increasingly at the middle and high school levels. That is, it will be important to reconcile narrowed definitions of readings…with the need to develop young people’s critical awareness as they engage with multiple sign systems” (26).
 We are in the conceptual age where “making meaning and connections will be valued as will focusing on the multiple possibilities of any situation over seeking one solution” (Beers 8).  The type of literacy students need to learn is “critically reading the media, popular culture, and texts in order to better read the world is a crucial aspect of critical consciousness and collective action” (Lipman 62). In other words, in a time of global warming and economic decline students need to become creative thinkers to solve problems. Multiliteracy and digital literacy become important in this conceptual age.

Teachers face the challenge of incorporating multiliteracy or digital literacy in the class room because neoliberal policies takes away their power making it seem that they are incapable of performing their job.  It is stated by Apple that, “Indeed , some states in the United States not only have specified the content that teachers are to teach, but also have regulated the only appropriate methods of teaching. Not following these specified ‘appropriate’ methods puts the teacher at risk of administration sanctions” (51). I believe that there should be some commonality in the curriculum taught in the U.S.; however, there needs to be faith in us educators that we can perform our jobs.  Teachers should be evaluated on how effective their methods are and not what methods they are using. Another way teachers lose their power is that “in education in particular, they constitute an offensive against teacher unions that are seen to be too powerful and much too costly” (Apple 40).  If there are no teacher unions then it will be extremely difficult for teachers to make changes to improve their students’ education.  Some schools that were successful in teaching multiliteracy or bilingual education are forced to change their methods due to pressures from national and state standards.  For example, at Brewer school “multiple and competing educational philosophies and ideologies were at work, but the school had a core of committed culturally relevant teachers, a bold new Latino principal committed to the community, a humanistic educational vision, and bilingual/bicultural education”  which contrasted with NCLB and other policies (Lipman 54). Eventually, the school changed course to meet the standards and high stakes tests.  When teachers are preparing students for high stakes tests they do not acknowledge students’ multiliteracies or digital literacies. Such is the case of a student named Collin described by Beers.  The student was successfully using his literacy skills to blog about environmental issues, yet he was failing in English and the teacher did not know he was an avid blogger. All in all, neoliberal policies make it difficult to incorporate multiliteracy, digital literacy in the class room because they are not seen as standard literacies.

Neoliberal policies are a challenge we have to face when teaching our students literacy. Creativity is needed to support our students’ literacies and teach them literacy skills of the conceptual age while meeting the required national and state standards. I hope this post was informative. As always, please feel free to comment on what has been presented.  Check back next week for a new post on literacy.

Monday, June 6, 2011

Multiple Literacies

Hello my blog followers! Last week I discussed E.D. Hirsch’s theory that literacy instruction can be improved by teaching students content or background knowledge for a national literacy. Much of the content knowledge was specific to the U.S. culture. This week I would like to discuss the concept of using students’ multiple literacies and cultures to improve literacy education.  The concepts and theories I will be drawing from come mostly from Mari Haneda, but I will be discussing other professionals as well. Mari Haneda’s theory is about multiple literacies used by English Language Learners.

Haneda and other professionals have stressed that students use multiple languages or literacies. She states, “the concept of multiple literacies is important because ELL inevitably have to engage in a wide range of literacy practices –across contexts, in different languages, in different domains, and for various purposes” (Haneda 338). In essence, Haneda claims that there are literary practices at home, in the community, and school. Similarly, Baker introduces the concept of trilingualism, which is the idea that students use different languages/literacies according to the home, school, or professional settings they are in.  The basic idea is that people use multiple litercaies depending on the environment they are in and who they are communicating with. One example of how an ELL used literacy at home is the following, “Nan was able to draw on her existing artistic and performance skills to compensate for her limited English, whereas at school she was not able to access them fully” (Haneda 138). Nan uses her artistic skills with her English skills to communicate with her family at home. Another example used by Haneda is a student that communicated on his own website.  Outside of school,  “ELLs strategically and agentively use literacy for their own personal purposes to express their personal feelings and opinions, seek and exchange information, maintain and develop social relations, construct desirable identities for themselves, act as language brokers for the family, and improve their English” (Haneda 340) . It is clear that students have the skills to communicate when literacy serves a purpose and benefits them. The examples that Haneda provides support that all of the literacies are effective to the purpose they are being used for. I believe that this proves that there is no such thing as a primitive language and that “languages reflect, in vocabulary, the needs and interest of their speakers” (Stubbs 71).  

I think if we want our students to master literacy than we must do as Haneda suggests and “boundary cross” or help students make the connection between home and school literacies. The first step to boundary crossing is acknowledging and respecting the literacies that students use at home and in their community. Part of a teachers’ job is to communicate with students, and communicating with students is difficult if we do not acknowledge their multiple literacies. Learning about students’ multiple literacies is discussed in “English Language Learners in the Class Room” when the professionals share the differences between Chinese, Spanish, and English languages. For instance, it is explained in their discussion that a complete sentence in English requires a subject, verb, and object while some Chinese sentences do not require a subject or verb. I have found that knowing some basic rules of other languages such as Chinese has helped me tutor writing ELL.  For instance, I know that some cultures do not cite sources and it is believed as an honor to copy someone’s work. When I tutor someone that believes this I must respect their culture while explaining the concept of citing sources to them, so that they do not get in trouble for plagiarizing.  Baker also gives examples of how educators can learn about their students’ literacies. In particular, Baker asks her students to get into groups and discuss how they communicate at home. This activity could definitely be used in an English or AIS Literacy class as a way for the teacher to get to know students. The importance of learning about our students’ literacies and cultures is that we are able to communicate with them and help them further improve their literacy skills.

After we have explored our students literacies and culture we are then able to create lessons on literacy that unify the literacies.  By connecting the multiple literacies in the class room students will be open to learning about literacy. One example that Haneda provides is about a group of teachers that “…collaboratively created lessons that drew on community resources in order to make learning personally relevant to their students” (342).  In other words, home community, and school are linked making lessons significant and valid to students.  Another example of how this linkage can be achieved is the Indigenous schools discussed by Lomawaima and McCarty. The students in the Indigenous schools are taught a bilingual and bi-cultural education. The linkage of the litearcies and cultures requires that we invite members from our students’ communities. I agree that we should make an effort to bring in the outside communities to support students and educate students on diversity. Providing students opportunities share and analyze art work, literature, and other forms of communication from their cultures would show students that there are diverse forms of literacy that are equally effective.  

The term multiple literacies springs to mind various languages and how we adapt those languages based on the settings we are in. However, I would also like to point out that media literacy should be addressed in the class room as well. Video clips, word processors, social networks, texting are all forms of literacy. Our students use media every day to communicate at home and their community, so we should use media literacy in the class room. Please take the time to watch the following video clip that argues media is a valid literacy that students use along with their other multiple literacies; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvQicn2WwTo. One way we can intergrate the multiple literacies is by having students create their own blogs about their culture, make a website about family traditions, compose their own bilingual short stories, make dictionaries with vocabulary from their multiple literacies, and write a paper on how they choose what literacy to use in certain social settings.

All in all, I think teachers should acknowledge students’ multiple literacies. Students will appreciate the fact that we welcome their multiple literacies and cultures. Moreover, integrating multiple literacies in the classroom will improve the education of literacy. I hope you have gained something from my literacy blog. Please check back next week for my new post!